On March 27, 2025, the Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation convened to consider the nomination of Arielle Roth for the position of Assistant Secretary of Commerce for Communications and Information. If confirmed, Roth will lead the National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA), overseeing pivotal programs aimed at expanding broadband access nationwide.
Senate Confirmation Hearing Highlights
During the hearing, Chairman Ted Cruz (R-TX) endorsed Roth, citing her extensive experience and dedication to telecommunications policy. Cruz emphasized Roth’s potential to address challenges within the Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment (BEAD) program, which has faced criticism for delays and inefficiencies. Roth expressed her commitment to expediting broadband deployment, stating her intent to connect every American to high-speed internet “as expeditiously, efficiently, and effectively as possible.” However, she refrained from providing specific commitments regarding potential changes to the BEAD program, indicating a need to consult with NTIA staff and stakeholders.
The Technological Neutrality Debate
A significant point of discussion centered on the BEAD program’s technological preferences. The current administration has advocated for a “tech-neutral” approach, potentially broadening eligibility to include satellite providers and fixed-wireless providers. Proponents argue this could accelerate deployment in underserved areas, while critics contend it might divert funds from more reliable fiber-optic solutions.
Senator Ed Markey (D-MA) questioned Roth on this issue, expressing concern over shifting priorities that could favor certain technologies or companies. Roth responded, “My mission will be to deliver broadband to the American people… not to serve any individual or company.”
State-Level Concerns and Legislative Responses
State officials have expressed concern about potential federal changes to the BEAD program. A bipartisan group of 115 state legislators sent a letter to Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, urging that any modifications be optional to avoid disrupting state plans and delaying deployment. They emphasized the importance of maintaining state authority over broadband programs to effectively meet local needs.
Arielle Roth’s nomination to lead the NTIA is progressing amid complex discussions about the future of the BEAD program and national broadband deployment strategies. As the confirmation process advances, stakeholders at both the federal and state levels will closely monitor how potential policy shifts may impact efforts to bridge the digital divide and achieve equitable broadband access nationwide.
